Soft Toe vs Steel Toe vs Composite Safety Toe Work Boots

Soft Toe vs Steel Toe Work Boots

For a lot of people, steel toe boots are the very definition of safety work boots. This isn’t always the case, though. Below, you’ll see some great steel toe alternatives.

Some soft toe work boots also get to provide ample forefoot protection in some instances. If you’re wondering which one will be a good pick for you, make sure to read all the way through. We’ll discuss the various merits of these work boots.

In This Article

In this article, we’ll provide you with a comprehensive outline of soft-toe work boots, steel-toe work boots, and composite work boots. This includes an explanation of the various features of each, as well as some pros and cons. Then, we will provide some various FAQs regarding these different types of footwear.

But while at it, have a look at the various options in the market for each type of these workplace shoes. Just click on either of the links below.

Soft, Steel & Composite Toe Work Boots Defined

To get this guide started, let’s first define what these safety toe shoes actually are. It’s easy to get acquainted with these shoes since their names directly describe what they are.

What can cause confusion is the fact that both offer practically the same things but in varying degrees. One has a more general appeal, while the other provides specific functionality that not everyone might find useful. By knowing what they are and what they can do for you, you can go for the one that will cater to your needs adequately.

Definitions

Soft Toe Definition

What is a Soft Toe Work Boot?

Simply put, soft toe boots refer to the work footwear that doesn’t come with steel or other solid material toe caps. Some pairs may be reinforced with composite materials like rubber or thick fabric among other things. In most cases, however, they just have the same material as the rest of the shoe upper.

As not every workplace poses safety risks on your forefoot, not all employers require the toughest alloy toe shoes for the job. There are instances where steel toes are prohibited due to their magnetic properties. Some soft toe boots provide good alternatives as they can already provide ample protection. Just be sure to check the requirements of your workplace before committing to boots without safety toe caps.

Steel Toe Definition

What is a Steel Toe Work Boot?

Again, as the name suggests, steel toe work boots are the types of safety footwear that come with steel caps on their toe boxes. The safety toe work boots provide protection against compression, stubs, and sharp objects.

They’re also usually very heavy duty as the steel component won’t easily wear out. The best ones are also constructed to keep up with the metal addition, because if they don’t, this part can wear out the upper material easily.

Typically required for workers in the heavy industries, steel toe work boots also usually have other safety features incorporated to their design. This is why they’re also often referred to as safety boots.

What's a Composite Toe

Composite Toe Definition?

A composite material is one that is made of two different constituent materials to make a stronger and better quality product. The constituent materials can differ in terms of physical or chemical properties.

This safety boot provides mid range protection. However, it provides a number of advantages. For instance, you can pass security metal detectors when wearing a pair of work boots with composite safety toes, unlike the case with steel toe options. Additionally, they might not be as heavy due to the different material used.

Soft Toe vs Steel Toe vs Composite Toe Comparison Chart

Features Soft Toe Steel Toe Composite Toe
Safety Poor Excellent Fair
Comfort Fair Fair Excellent
Price Affordable Mostly Fair Mostly Expensive

Soft Toe vs Steel Toe vs Composite Toe Work Boots: Breaking it Down

While they have striking differences, steel toe and soft toe boots also have a few things in common. These similarities could easily render your decision making process pretty tough. So to help you find your match, here’s a quick comparison between the different options. We will evaluate these boots each based on three factors – safety, comfort, and affordability.

You can compare this guide to your personal preferences and requirements to see which style of boots is best for you.

Breaking it Down

Feature #1: Safety

As these shoes are also known as safety shoes by some folks, it’s very important for a pair of work boots to have a number of good safety features in it. Again, the jobs that require their inclusion in an employee’s work gear come with a number of dangers. Hence it’s important that they provide some protection to the wearer.

For a pair of shoes to be considered safe for industrial and other occupational applications, they have to meet or exceed various safety standards. The Occupational Safety and Health Administration has its own regulations and recommendations for various industries. ASTM testings are also available to gauge the performance of a pair of work boots.

It’s important to note, however, that soft toe and steel toe boots, however, have varying degrees of protection. Just how different are they? We’ll discuss them in detail below:

Soft Toe

Soft Toe Boots

Most soft toe boots do not have reinforced toe box areas to provide forefoot and toe protection. This makes them more vulnerable and unsuitable for most industrial workplaces. However, some varieties still have some kind of reinforcement on the area. This means that they can still provide some protection to wearers.

Despite not having toe protection, soft toe boots can still have other safety features. The best ones will have an excellent outsole. They’re constructed to provide electrical hazard safety, underfoot protection, and slip-resistance. So if your forefoot isn’t exactly in danger of being crushed, sliced, or punctured, these boots will be perfect for you. Just be absolutely sure that they aren’t required of your workplace before committing to a purchase.

Steel Toe

Steel Toe Boots

Steel toe boots are usually packed with safety features as they’re often used in high-risk work environments. This is why they come with a solid reinforcement to their toe boxes as wearers will be in danger of falling heavy items, punctures, and cuts. These are very durable boots and are resistant to many workplace hazards. Many are also waterproof.

With these dangers in mind, it’s also expected that they come with other safety features as well. The best ones will also protect your feet from electrical hazards, slips, and underfoot accidents. These boots are clearly the safest on the market, but they might be excessive if they aren’t required of your job.

Composite Toe

Composite Toe Boots

These safety toe boots will protect your feet from falling objects. However, for very heavy objects the offered protection might not be sufficient. Actually, these shoes only meet only a few of the threshold safety requirements in the ASTM standards tests.

In terms of electrical hazard safety, composite toe boots are as good as steel safety toe shoes.

Verdict

Winner: Steel toe boots

When it comes to your safety, these shoes will always be the better choice. They provide maximum protection, but may be excessive if your job doesn’t include the hazards that these protect against.

Feature #2: Comfort

The jobs that require safety boots also tend to be punishing on one’s feet. This and the fact that you’re going to wear them for long periods make it all the more important that they be comfortable. With a good fit, excellent arch support, and ample cushioning, your feet won’t feel battered by the end of the day. This is irrespective of you having to move and stand around in them for most of your shift.

Soft toe and steel toe boots also tend to come with varying degrees of comfort. So this feature can be a deciding factor for some buyers.

Soft Toe

Soft Toe Boots

The best soft toe boots are usually equipped with ample underfoot cushioning, a shock absorbing outer sole, reinforced shanks, and the right upper dimensions to keep your feet comfortable in them all day long. Some even come with additional features like padded collars to further support your feet.

The fact that they’re also typically lighter than steel toe boots also help make soft toe boots more comfortable than steel toe boots.

Steel Toe

Steel Toe Boots

One set back to most steel toe boots is that it’s hard to find a pair that’s utterly comfortable. The steel cap tends to add a substantial amount of weight to the footwear and they can tire out your legs if you’re not used to them just yet.

They also tend to take up room inside the toe box which explains why a lot of people complain about these areas being too narrow in some pairs. Due to this construction, some people experience pains because their toes rub into the steel cap.

While there are products that do not have such issues, the ones that do cause such complaints are more common. This is why it’s very important to watch out for such factors when shopping for a steel toe work boot.

Composite Toe

Composite Toe Boots

Composite safety toe work shoes have two main comfort features.

One, they are poor heat conductors. Therefore, if you work outside in the weather elements your feet will remain comfortable. You will not suffer from high temperatures during hot days. And you will not get chilly in the winter.

Two, composite materials are very light and hence the shoes made out of these materials are also very light. If you walk around in your safety boots, this is a welcome feature, as the weight is often the primary hindrance of wearing these boots.

Verdict

Winner: Composite toe boots

The combination of light weight and insulation from weather elements is just perfect. If your job allows it, we would recommend these boots.

Feature #3: Affordable Price

Not everyone is ready to shell out a lot of money for a pair of work shoes. This is why the price is also an important point when it comes to choosing between steel toe and soft toe boots. These two items tend to come at different price points. And hence is a good basis when making a choice from the three.

Soft Toe

Soft Toe Boots

Unless a pair of soft toe boots uses advanced technology and high-end material to add protection to its toe box, you can expect these shoes to come with a friendly price tag. You can already find a high-quality pair that will hold up to your tasks with ease at a range that won’t break the bank.

Steel Toe

Steel Toe Boots

While there are “cheap” steel toe boots available today, they are still problematic in two ways. One, they’re usually very flimsy. In most cases, normal use can already create holes and tears in the upper material because the steel rubs against it.

Two, their “affordable price” is still relatively high for a pair of shoes. So you’d expect them to last a bit longer than their actual lifespan.

Composite Toe

Composite Toe Boots

These safety shoes do not come cheap. If we were to compare composite toe boots vs steel toe safety shoe prices, the former would have the most options being more expensive than the latter. They use relatively advanced technology as far as boots are concerned, and they come with the price tag to match.

Verdict

Winner: Soft toe boots

At the end of the day, the best steel toe work boots are investment pieces. This might not suit everyone’s budget, especially if you don’t really need as much foot protection in your line of work.

Final Recount

Soft Toe Boots: 1

Steel Toe Boots: 1

Composite Toe Boots: 1

These three kinds of work boots have different target markets.

Each of the three has it's strengths and weaknesses. Therefore, some of the factors that would push you towards buying a certain type of boot are work environment and employer specifications. Clearly, it is difficult to pick a clear winner when so much of it is based on personal circumstances. However, if you do have the option between them, then use the factors above to make the most informed choice.

Pros & Cons

Pros & Cons

Soft Toe Boots

 Pros 
  • Lightweight
  • Composite toe varieties still offer good protection
  • Roomier toe box
  • Can have other protective features
  • Friendlier price
  • Safer to use in workplaces with magnetic risks
 Cons 
  • Won’t be able to protect your feet from a wide range of dangers

Steel Toe Boots

 Pros 
  • Provides high amount of toe protection from compression, puncture, and other dangers
  •  Solid and sturdy
 Cons 
  • Can be dangerous to wear in workplaces with magnetic machinery
  • Quite heavy
  • Toe box can wear out easily

Composite Toe Boots

 Pros 
  • Lightweight
  • Electrical hazard protection
  • Moderate toe safety
  • Can pass metal detection safety checks
  • Weather elements insulation
 Cons 
  • Fairly expensive

What Does the Law Say About Toe Protection in Work Boots?

The Occupational Safety and Health Administration Standard Number 1910.136 covers workplace protective footwear. It says employers need to make sure that their employees use protective footwear when their work involves foot injury dangers. These include threats from rolling or falling objects, electrical hazard, and sharp items that can pierce the sole.

The directive notes that the protective footwear employees need to wear should comply with any of the following standards:

  • ASTM F-2412-2005 or the Standard Test Methods for Foot Protection
  • ASTM F-2413-2005 or the Standard Specification for Performance Requirements for Protective Footwear
  • ANSI Z41-1999 or the American National Standard for Personal Protection – Protective Footwear
  • ANSI Z41-1991 or the American National Standard for Personal Protection – Protective Footwear

OSHA conducts regular inspections to work sites. Hence it’s not impossible for the agency to learn about a business’ failure to comply with their directives. This can then result in sanctions, warnings, and fines. While they might not be the heftiest of punishments out there, they can still be enough motivation for businesses to operate according to the set safety standards.

In many cases, however, employers have the initiative to implement rules on wearing safety gear, among their employees. It’s better to be strict with the rules to keep their employees safe instead of cheap out on work gear only to end up spending more on medical bills and fines. The loss in productivity a business will experience after the accident can also be very costly. On the contrary, while taking caution is done easily.

Other Types of Toe Caps Used in Safety Shoes

What are the other materials that can be used to make composite toe boots? Here are a few of the most popular examples:

  • Ceramic
  • Plastic
  • Rubber
  • Kevlar
  • Carbon fiber

Each has their own strengths and advantages so it’s best to keep those in mind when choosing.  Note, as well, that the type of material used can also affect the pricing of the product. Some of them are very affordable but others can be more expensive than your average steel toe boots.

The most important thing to remember when opting for composite toe work boots is that they don’t always match the safety provided by steel toe boots. They may already provide enough protection for some workplaces but most of them won’t be able to resist the force and effects of a chainsaw. So if your feet will be exposed to such dangers, steel toe boots might still be your best choices.

Making The Right Choice For You

So you have a great grasp on the differences between these boots, but still are having trouble making your choice. In this section, we’ll give you a few quick tips for choosing between these types of boots.

First, and most importantly, you must see if any type of boot is specifically required of your job. If your job already has a precedent in place, then you should pick a pair of boots that meets this requirement. If in doubt, ask a manager to be sure. So if your work requires some toe cap boots, then that’s what you should get.

However, if you are self-employed or your work allows more flexibility, it really comes down to personal choice. Outline the factors that are most important to you in a pair of boots first, and then match these factors to our lists above. If safety is your primary concern, then you should lean more toward steel-toed boots. However, if comfort is a concern, then soft-toed boots are likely to get the job done better.

There are boots that offer the best of both worlds, safety and comfort. These are usually more toward composite boots, but be aware that these tend to cost more. However, a boot is something that you are wearing constantly throughout the day. It might be tough to put a price on the degree that a comfortable boot will help with your ease of work. Therefore, investing in a pair that will keep you comfortable is very worth it most of the time.

Overall, unless your work requires a certain boot, it will really come down to personal preference.

Conclusion

Making the choice between soft toe vs. steel toe boots is quite a no-brainer for a lot of people, as the latter is straightforward when it comes to providing the best foot protection. If you’re just thinking of getting the extra protection even if you don’t need it, then, you have more options to choose from.

Ezoicreport this adAt the end of the day, those who absolutely need the best foot protection should opt for steel toe boots, while those who don’t might be better off with the soft toe alternatives.